Nationwide Car Insurance Review

(January 2025)

Nationwide-Car-Insurance-Review

In This Article

Our Verdict

Nationwide-Car-Insurance

Nationwide is a reputable insurance provider offering a broad spectrum of insurance options, including property, business, personal, and, of course, auto insurance. With extensive coverage choices, various discounts, and distinctive features, Nationwide strives to meet the diverse needs of drivers across the United States. However, you should thoroughly evaluate the advantages and disadvantages to determine if Nationwide suits your specific requirements.

Pros

  • Enjoy affordable rates for various driver profiles, including good drivers, senior drivers, and drivers with speeding tickets or poor credit
  • Benefit from extensive coverage options, such as accident forgiveness, new car replacement, gap insurance, and a diminishing deductible
  • Take advantage of two usage-based insurance programs (SmartRide and SmartMiles)
  • Access coverage in 46 states and Washington, D.C., providing widespread availability
  • Utilize robust auto insurance discounts, including safe driver, good student, and multi-policy discounts
  • Opt for paperless documentation for bills
  • Set up automatic payments

Cons

  • Expect higher-than-average rates for drivers with a DUI conviction
  • Face limited availability, as Nationwide does not offer car insurance in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts
  • Find no dedicated rideshare insurance option for ride-sharing drivers
  • Be aware that ID cards printed from a home computer may not constitute valid proof of insurance in all states

Who Nationwide Is Best For

Use Nationwide car insurance if you:

  • Value affordability
  • Desire a wide range of coverage options and the ability to customize policies
  • Appreciate the convenience of bundling multiple insurance products with a single provider
  • Prefer to have access to usage-based insurance programs
  • Reside in one of the 46 states or Washington, D.C., where Nationwide operates

Who Nationwide Isn't Right For

Avoid Nationwide car insurance if you:

  • Have a history of DUI convictions, as Nationwide’s rates for this category tend to be higher than competitors
  • Place a strong emphasis on exceptional customer service
  • Live in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts, where Nationwide car insurance is not available
  • Prioritize a seamless collision repair experience
  • Require specialized rideshare insurance coverage for work as a ride-sharing driver

What Nationwide Offers

What-Nationwide-Offers

Nationwide offers a comprehensive range of car insurance products and services, including:

  • Personal auto coverages
  • Vehicle coverages
  • Classic car insurance
  • Roadside assistance
  • Auto ID card
  • Paperless policy
  • Accident forgiveness
  • Car insurance discounts
  • Mobile App (Google Play & Apple Store)

Nationwide Details

Personal Auto Coverages

When it comes to personal auto coverages, think of them as safeguards for you, your passengers, and others on the road in case of an accident. Bodily injury liability coverage takes care of medical bills and lost income for others if you’re at fault, shielding you from legal liabilities. Property damage liability coverage handles damages to another person’s vehicle or property, including legal defense costs. Personal injury protection (PIP) covers medical expenses and lost wages for you and your passengers, regardless of fault.

Concerned about uninsured drivers? Uninsured motorist coverage steps in to cover costs for you and your passengers if they cause an accident. It includes Uninsured Motorist Property Damage (UMPD) for vehicle damage and Uninsured Motorist Bodily Injury (UMBI) for medical expenses and other damages.

Underinsured motorist coverage protects you from drivers whose insurance doesn’t cover all accident costs, ensuring you’re not left with the bill. Medical payments coverage (Med Pay) handles immediate medical expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of fault.

Vehicle Coverages

With collision coverage, this one kicks in to handle the repair costs for your vehicle if you’re involved in a crash, regardless of who’s at fault. So, whether you bump into someone or they bump into you, collision coverage has your back. Just remember, there’s usually a deductible you’ll need to cover, but it’s worth it to ensure your wheels can get back on the road.

Then there’s comprehensive coverage, also known as “other than collision.” This one steps up for a variety of scenarios, like vandalism, theft, weather damage, and even run-ins with animals. Whether it’s a rogue hailstorm or a mischievous raccoon, comprehensive coverage helps foot the bill for repairs, keeping your ride in tip-top shape.

About towing and labor coverage? Imagine your car’s stuck on the side of the road or out of commission after an accident. That’s where this coverage comes in handy, providing the assistance you need to get your vehicle moving again when you’re not covered by collision insurance.

Next up, rental car expense coverage. Nobody wants to be left without wheels while their car’s in the shop. This coverage steps in to make sure you have a temporary ride sorted, whether it’s a rental car or another form of transportation, so you can carry on with your day-to-day while your vehicle gets patched up.

And then there’s gap coverage. It bridges the difference between what you owe and what your insurer pays out, saving you from being stuck with a hefty bill.

Remember, though, gap coverage won’t cover everything. Your deductible, mechanical repairs, medical expenses, and other costs aren’t included. But when it comes to covering the difference between what you owe and what your car’s worth, gap insurance is the way to go, especially if you’re leasing or financing your vehicle.

Special Auto Coverages

Consider enhancing your auto coverage with accident forgiveness to protect against rate hikes after your first at-fault accident or minor violation. Roadside assistance offers 24/7 support for emergencies like fuel shortages, tire changes, jump-starts, or tows, extending to you and your family members in any vehicle.

Seamlessly manage assistance through a user-friendly app or insurer’s website. Drive safely to enjoy a vanishing deductible, reducing by $100 annually up to $500, potentially vanishing entirely with a safe driving record. Additionally, the total loss deductible waiver ensures you won’t pay the deductible for physical damage in the event of a total loss, providing peace of mind during stressful times.

Nationwide Classic Car Insurance By Hagerty

When insuring your classic car with Hagerty, you’re ensuring specialized coverage tailored to collectors like you. With guaranteed value coverage, rest assured knowing you’ll receive the full insured amount in case of a covered total loss, minus a deductible. Plus, it’s premiums are up to 21% lower than standard auto insurance, making it affordable to protect your passion.

You’ll appreciate the flexibility of its usage allowance, without fixed mileage limits. Whether it’s a spontaneous weekend joy ride or a leisurely spin, you’re covered. And when it comes to maintenance and repairs, you’re in control. Access its seasoned claims team and choose your preferred repair shop.

Its coverage doesn’t stop at vintage cars; it extends to a variety of collector vehicles, including antique cars, muscle cars, classic trucks, motorcycles, and unique modifications. Just by using your vehicle for club events, exhibitions, tours, and occasional pleasure drives, you qualify.

Even collector trucks receive special considerations, addressing hauling and towing needs. Its comprehensive coverage includes protection against fire, vandalism, and other mishaps, along with liability coverage for injuries to others or property damage.

As a Hagerty member, you unlock additional perks. Enjoy coverage for automobilia, spare parts, and roadside assistance through the Hagerty Drivers Club. Plus, gain access to exclusive discounts and valuation tools, along with automotive resources to further enhance your collector experience.

Discounts

Take advantage of the numerous discounts Nationwide provides to reduce your car insurance premiums. By bundling policies such as home and car insurance, you can pocket an average of $646 in savings. Programs like SmartRide offer discounts for safe driving habits, while SmartMiles bases charges on mileage for those who don’t drive often. Keeping a clean driving record and excelling as a student also make you eligible for discounts. Whether you bundle multiple policies or opt for motorcycle or boat insurance, you can enjoy savings. Bundling not only cuts costs but also simplifies management and guarantees top-notch customer service.

Where Nationwide Stands Out

Where-Nationwide-Stands-Out

Affordable Rates for Various Driver Profiles

Nationwide offers some of the most competitive rates out there, no matter what kind of driver you are. Whether you have a spotless record, you’re a seasoned driver, or even if you’ve had a few speeding tickets or struggled with credit, Nationwide’s has options that won’t break the bank.

Robust Coverage Options and Customization

It has a wide array of coverage options, meaning you can customize your policy to fit your exact needs. Need accident forgiveness? Check. Want protection for a brand-new car? No problem! From gap insurance to a diminishing deductible, Nationwide gives you the flexibility to build a policy that gives you peace of mind every time you hit the road.

Usage-Based Insurance Programs

Nationwide offers not one, but two usage-based insurance programs: SmartRide and SmartMiles. SmartRide keeps tabs on your driving habits and can score you discounts of up to 40% for safe driving. Meanwhile, SmartMiles is perfect for those who don’t rack up a ton of miles behind the wheel. It’s a pay-per-mile option that could save you a bundle if you’re not out there on the road every day.

Where Nationwide Falls Short

Higher Rates for Drivers with DUI Convictions

If you have a DUI conviction on your record, you might find Nationwide’s rates a bit steep. On average, it’ll cost you around $3,083 annually, which is higher than what some other companies are charging. This could be a significant concern for you if you’re in this situation.

Limited Availability and No Rideshare Insurance Option

Nationwide’s coverage isn’t an option in four states: Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, and Massachusetts. Plus, if you’re into ride-sharing, there’s another hiccup. It does not offer specific insurance for ride-sharing drivers, which could be a letdown if you’re part of that growing industry.

How to Qualify for Nationwide

To qualify for Nationwide car insurance, you’ll typically need to meet the following general requirements:

  • Possess a valid driver’s license and a clean driving record (or disclose any violations or accidents)
  • Provide personal information, such as your name, address, date of birth, and contact details.
  • Provide details about the vehicle(s) you wish to insure, including make, model, year, and vehicle identification number (VIN)
  • Meet any specific eligibility criteria based on your state’s insurance regulations

It’s important to note that Nationwide may have additional eligibility requirements or underwriting guidelines based on factors like your driving history, credit score, or location.

How to Apply for Nationwide

How-to-Apply-for-Nationwide

Applying for Nationwide car insurance can be done in a few different ways:

  • Through Online: Visit Nationwide’s website and use its online quoting tool to provide your information and receive a personalized quote.
  • Using Phone: Call a Nationwide agent or a local Nationwide office to discuss your coverage needs and initiate the application process over the phone.

Alternatives to Nationwide

If Nationwide doesn’t meet your specific needs or requirements, there are several alternative car insurance providers you may want to consider:

State Farm

State Farm, recognized by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners as the leading auto insurance provider in the U.S. State Farm offers coverage across the nation, albeit excluding new policies in Massachusetts and Rhode Island. Its offerings include standard types of coverage such as bodily injury, property damage liability, collision, comprehensive, and personal injury protection.

GEICO

A prominent player known for its competitive rates and extensive coverage options. Its emphasis on top-notch customer service and a user-friendly mobile app might catch your eye if you’re after a seamless experience. GEICO’s array of products ranges from basic coverage to add-ons like mechanical breakdown insurance and roadside assistance. Whether you’re seeking a full-coverage policy or minimum coverage, GEICO has options tailored to your needs.

Progressive

Progressive which stands out with its competitive rates, especially for drivers with a DUI or poor credit. In fact, its average rates often beat the national average. Progressive offers coverage types that other companies may not, including rideshare and gap insurance. Plus, it provides a unique perk: coverage for vet bills if your pet gets injured in a crash, available to those with collision insurance.

Customer Reviews

In the realm of customer satisfaction and ratings, Nationwide holds a respectable position across multiple platforms. According to the latest J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Insurance Digital Experience Study, Nationwide secures the third spot, indicating a positive digital interaction experience for customers. Additionally, Forbes awards it a solid 5.0 rating, while USA Today also gives it a commendable 5.0. Furthermore, Nationwide boasts an impressive overall BBB A+ score, reflecting its commitment to quality service.

Pro Tips

  • Take the time to explore offerings from multiple insurers
  • Look beyond just the big national insurance companies
  • Assess your coverage needs
  • Inquire about discounts
  • Improve your credit score
  • Consider combining more than one policy
  • Opt for higher deductibles

Recap

Nationwide Car Insurance offers a comprehensive range of coverage options catering to various driver profiles. While it excels in providing affordable rates and extensive coverage choices, it may not be the best fit for drivers with DUI convictions or those seeking specialized rideshare insurance.

Nevertheless, Nationwide stands out with its usage-based insurance programs and widespread availability in 46 states and Washington, D.C. Customer reviews and ratings from reputable sources like J.D. Power, Forbes, USA Today, and the BBB underscore Nationwide’s commitment to quality service and customer satisfaction.

Related Articles

Become a

S'witty Kiwi Credit Insider!

Get the latest credit tips and hacks in your inbox!