Our Verdict
Firstrade prides itself as a self-directed brokerage for active traders and investors seeking low-cost access to a wide range of investment products, robust trading tools, and customizable platforms. Its commission-free trading, options trading capabilities, and research resources make it a compelling choice to embrace if you prefer hands-on portfolio management.
Conversely, Betterment shines as a robo-advisor, automating investment decisions based on your risk tolerance and goals. If you prioritize convenience and long-term growth, Betterment offers tax-loss harvesting, portfolio rebalancing, and a user-friendly interface, albeit with a more limited investment selection compared to Firstrade.
Why Choose Firstrade
Who Firstrade Is Best For
Use Firstrade if you:
- Want low-cost trading
- Desire a user-friendly platform
- Seek access to a wide range of investments
- Require no minimum balance
- Need robust research and educational resources
Who Firstrade Isn't Best For
Choose a better alternative to Firstrade if you:
- Eye advanced trading tools
- Prioritize extensive research and analysis
- Prefer high-touch customer service
- Seek a wide range of investment products
- Want premium account features
- Desire a strong mobile experience
Why Choose Betterment
Who Betterment Is Best For
Betterment is your best choice if you’re someone who:
- Looks for automated investment management
- Desires a hands-off investment approach
- Prefers low-cost investing
- Seeks goal-based financial planning
- Wants access to personalized advice
- Needs tax-efficient investment strategies
Who Betterment Is Best For
Consider Firstrade or any other alternative to Betterment if you’re an individual who:
- Wants to actively manage investments
- Needs a wide range of investment options
- Prefers a hands-on approach to financial planning
- Desires personalized financial advice
- Is looking for tax-loss harvesting and advanced tax strategies
- Requires a high level of customization in investment portfolios
Firstrade vs Betterment: Main Differences
| Firstrade | Betterment |
Ideal For |
|
|
Main Features |
|
|
Pricing | Firstrade offers commission-free trading for stocks, ETFs, options, and mutual funds. This means you pay no direct fee for these trades. Where Firstrade Charges: While trading is commission-free, there are other areas where fees apply: Bonds: Firstrade uses a markup or markdown on bond prices instead of charging a commission. This means you pay more or less than the bond’s quoted price. Margin interest: If you use margin to borrow money for investments, you pay interest on the amount you borrow. The interest rate varies based on the amount you borrow. Broker-assisted trades: If you prefer to trade with a live broker, there’s a fee of $19.95 per trade for stocks and ETFs, and $19.95 plus $0.50 per contract for options. | Betterment is a robo-advisor, which means it uses algorithms to manage your investments based on your financial goals. Unlike traditional brokerages, Betterment charges a management fee rather than commissions on trades.
Management Fee: Betterment’s core service comes with a management fee. You have two options: $4 monthly fee: This is the default option. 0.25% annual fee: You can switch to this fee structure by maintaining a balance of $20,000 or more or by setting up recurring deposits of $250 or more per month.
Premium Service: For an additional fee of 0.65% annually, you can access a dedicated financial advisor for personalized advice. This tier requires a minimum balance of $100,000.
Betterment at Work (401(k) plans): There’s a base fee, a record-keeping fee per participant, and an advisory fee of 0.25% annually.
One cool thing is that Betterment doesn’t charge commissions on trades. Also, it calculates fees based on your daily account balance, accrued daily, and charged monthly or upon withdrawal and there are no inactivity fees. |
>>>PRO TIPS: Best Tax Software of 2023
Firstrade vs Betterment: Standout Features
Firstrade Standout Features
No Commission Trades: Firstrade allows you to trade stocks, ETFs, and options without paying commissions. This can lead to significant savings, especially if you’re an active trader.
User-Friendly Platform: The trading platform is designed with ease of use in mind. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced trader, you’re going to find the interface intuitive and straightforward.
Extensive Research Tools: Firstrade provides a variety of research resources, including real-time quotes, market news, and detailed stock analysis. These tools can help you make informed investment decisions.
Free Options Trading: Options trading is available without commissions or contract fees. This feature is especially beneficial if you’re interested in trading options regularly.
Educational Resources: The platform offers a range of educational materials to help you understand the markets and trading strategies better. From articles to webinars, these resources can enhance your trading knowledge.
Mobile App: Its mobile app lets you manage your investments on the go. It has many of the same features as the desktop platform, ensuring you stay connected to your portfolio.
Retirement Accounts: Firstrade supports various retirement accounts, including Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. This allows you to manage your long-term investments effectively.
Low Margin Rates: If you’re interested in margin trading, Firstrade offers competitive margin rates, which can help you manage your trading costs
Pros and Cons of Firstrade
Betterment Standout Features
Automated Investing: Betterment automates your investment process, making it easier for you to achieve your financial goals without needing to constantly monitor the market. It uses advanced algorithms to build and manage a diversified portfolio tailored to your risk tolerance and time horizon.
Goal-Based Investing: The platform helps you set specific financial goals, like retirement, buying a home, or saving for education. Each goal comes with a customized investment plan to help you reach it more effectively.
Tax-Efficient Strategies: With Betterment, you get tax-loss harvesting and other tax-efficient strategies to minimize your tax burden, potentially enhancing your after-tax returns.
Low Fees: Betterment offers low management fees compared to traditional financial advisors. Its transparent fee structure means you know exactly what you’re paying for.
Fractional Shares: Confidently invest in fractional shares and ensure every dollar you invest is put to work. This means you don’t have leftover cash sitting idle
Smart Rebalancing: Betterment automatically rebalances your portfolio to maintain your desired asset allocation. This keeps your investments aligned with your risk tolerance and financial goals.
Socially Responsible Investing (SRI): If you’re interested in ethical investing, Betterment offers SRI portfolios that focus on companies with positive social and environmental impacts.
Comprehensive Financial Advice: Betterment provides access to financial advisors for personalized advice. It offers various plans to suit different levels of advisory needs, from digital advice to a premium plan with unlimited phone consultations.
Retirement Planning: Betterment provides tools and advice for retirement planning, including personalized retirement plans and the ability to manage 401(k) rollovers and IRAs.
Pros and Cons of Firstrade
- Pros of Ally Invest
- Offers commission-free trading
- Provides a wide range of investment options
- Includes robust research tools
- Supports international accounts
- Integrates easy-to-use trading platforms
- Provides educational resources
- Offers options trading with no contract fees
- Cons of Ally Invest
- Lacks advanced trading tools for professionals
- Restricts availability of fractional shares
- Limits customer service to certain hours
- Provides no cryptocurrency trading
- Excludes futures and forex trading
- Has outdated mobile app interface
- Charges fees for broker-assisted trades
Pros and Cons of Betterment
- Pros
- Automates investing
- Offers low fees
- Provides goal-based planning
- Employs tax-efficient strategies
- Allows fractional shares
- Rebalances portfolios automatically
- Offers socially responsible investing options
- Provides access to financial advisors
- Offers high-yield cash accounts
- Simplifies retirement planning
- Cons
- Lacks physical branches
- Charges additional fees for premium plans
- Limits investment options compared to some brokers
- Lacks extensive educational resources
- Requires fees for tax-loss harvesting on certain accounts
Firstrade vs Betterment: Customer Reviews
Firstrade receives a poor rating of 2.4 out of a 5-star scale based on 6 customer reviews on TrustPilot. The reviews are not many enough to really understand the company’s service delivery. Betterment’s review on TrustPilot is even worse than Firstrade’s with a bad rating of 1.7 based on 28 customer reviews.
>>>GET SMARTER: Are Bank of America Business Loans Worth It?
Firstrade and Betterment Alternatives
Charles Schwab
Charles Schwab is a prominent financial services company offering a wide range of investment products and services. Known for its robust platform and extensive resources, Schwab caters to both novice and seasoned investors. You can open brokerage and retirement accounts, trade stocks, ETFs, and options, and access in-depth market research. It also provides robo-advisory services for automated portfolio management. While Schwab is popular for its commission-free trading, it’s essential to consider other fees, like account maintenance and margin interest. Additionally, it offers financial planning and advisory services you can leverage if you are seeking personalized guidance. With a strong reputation for customer service and a variety of account options, Schwab is a solid choice you can consider.
Interactive Brokers
Interactive Brokers is a powerhouse for serious investors and traders. Known for its advanced trading platform and low costs, it offers a vast array of investment options, including stocks, options, futures, currencies, bonds, and funds, across multiple global markets. While its platform can be overwhelming, especially if you’re a beginner, you’re going to appreciate its depth and customization. With extremely low commissions, competitive margin rates, and tools for advanced trading strategies, Interactive Brokers is a top choice if you seek maximum control over your investments. However, its complexity and focus on professional traders are factors to consider to know if it is suitable for you.
E*TRADE
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley is a well-established online brokerage offering a range of investment products and services. Popular for its robust trading platform, E*TRADE caters to both novice and experienced investors. While it’s not commission-free, it provides a competitive fee structure with options for various trading styles. You can access a plethora of investment options including stocks, ETFs, options, mutual funds, and bonds. The platform offers research tools, educational resources, and customer support to assist you in making informed investment decisions.
However, E*TRADE’s fee structure and specific offerings vary, so it’s essential to compare it with other brokers to find the best fit for your investment goals and needs.
Pro Tips
- Analyze your investment style: Determine if you prefer active trading, making frequent buy and sell decisions, or a hands-off approach that relies on automated investment strategies.
- Compare fee structures comprehensively: Evaluate not only commission fees but also other costs such as margin interest, bond markups, account transfer charges, and management fees to understand the overall cost of ownership.
- Define your financial goals clearly: Identify your long-term objectives, such as retirement savings, buying a home, or building wealth, to align your investment strategy accordingly.
- Gauge your investment knowledge accurately: Assess your understanding of financial markets, investment products, and risk tolerance to determine if you need a platform with extensive research tools or prefer a guided investment approach.
- Evaluate customer support options thoroughly: Consider factors like availability, response times, communication channels, and the quality of assistance provided to ensure your needs will be met.
Recap
Firstrade and Betterment cater to different investor profiles. Firstrade is ideal if you’re an active trader seeking control over your investments. It offers commission-free trading on stocks, ETFs, and options.
However, consider fees on other services. Betterment, on the other hand, is a robo-advisor that is suitable if you prefer a hands-off approach. It charges a management fee for automated portfolio management but lacks the flexibility of a traditional brokerage.
No Comment! Be the first one.