Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

(February 2025)

In This Article

Our Verdict

When comparing Fidelity Investments IRA with Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA, you notice that each platform offers unique strengths to cater to different investment preferences.

Fidelity is highly regarded for its user-friendly interface and diverse range of investment options, including crypto trading and thousands of mutual funds. It doesn’t charge advisory fees for smaller accounts and offers a seamless portfolio rebalancing system.

On the other hand, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA is ideal if you prefer a more automated approach. It offers a robo-advisor service that constructs and manages your portfolio based on your risk tolerance, all without charging advisory fees.

With Fidelity, you enjoy more personalization and the ability to leverage a wide range of research tools and expert support. Schwab’s robo-advisor solution, however, provides automatic rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting features that optimize your investment strategy with minimal effort on your part.

Ultimately, your choice hinges on whether you prefer the active involvement and diverse options of Fidelity or the automated, no-fee simplicity of Schwab. Both platforms can help you grow your retirement savings effectively depending on your investment style.

Why Choose Fidelity Investments IRA

Who Fidelity Investments IRA

is Best For

If you have a small business, are self-employed, or seek a reliable retirement plan with tax advantages, Fidelity’s IRA could be a strong fit for you. It’s particularly suited if you aim for simplicity with minimal administrative burden while maximizing your retirement savings.

For small business owners or those with fewer employees, Fidelity offers straightforward plans, which are easy to manage and come with options for pretax contributions and employer matching. Moreover, it provides a comprehensive selection of educational resources, making it suitable for those who want to grow retirement savings with professional guidance

Who Fidelity Investments IRA Isn't Right For

If you focus on niche or alternative investments, Fidelity’s offerings may not align with your preferences, as its selection tends toward traditional assets. If you prioritize a user-friendly platform with advanced trading features, Fidelity’s interface may feel overwhelming or lacking in customization.

Organizations that emphasize low-cost, no-fee options might also seek alternatives, as Fidelity’s fee structure may not always meet your expectations. If you operate internationally or deal with foreign investments, you may find better options with firms specializing in global markets.

Why Choose Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

Who Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA is Best For

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA works best for you if you prefer a diversified portfolio aligned with your risk tolerance and financial goals. Organizations focused on retirement planning can benefit from this IRA, as it provides tax advantages and low account minimums.

You might also find it ideal if you value transparency in investment strategies and enjoy having access to various asset classes. Schwab’s commitment to a technology-driven investment experience makes it suitable for tech-savvy investors aiming for long-term growth.

Who Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA Isn't Right For

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA may not suit you if you prefer a hands-on investment approach. If you require access to alternative investments, such as real estate or private equity, this service lacks those options, focusing primarily on ETFs.

This option emphasizes automated portfolio management, which can feel limiting for those wanting to select individual stocks. If you prioritize socially responsible investing and need specific ESG criteria, Schwab’s selection of ETFs may not fully meet your preferences, limiting your ability to invest according to your values.

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Main Differences

Main Differences

Fidelity Investments IRA

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

Overview

Offers you a range of IRAs with no minimum investment, focusing on low costs and diverse investment options

Provides automated IRAs with no management fees and a customizable portfolio structure

Types of IRAs Offered

Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA, and Fidelity Go

Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and SEP IRA.

Investment Strategy

Primarily invests in Fidelity Flex mutual funds and ETFs

Utilizes ETFs across multiple asset classes based on individual risk tolerance and goal

Account Minimum

$0 minimum for Fidelity Go and standard IRAs

$5,000 minimum for the Intelligent Portfolios, $25,000 for premium features

Fees

0.35% advisory fee for balances over $25,000; no other fees

No management fees; additional charges for premium planning services

Investment Options

Offers you a wide array of ETFs, mutual funds, and options; over 10,000 investment choices

Provides you with customizable portfolios with up to 20 asset classes, focusing on ETFs

Portfolio Management

Offers you automated management with human oversight for larger accounts

Fully automated portfolio management with rebalancing as needed

Research Tools

Extensive research tools, including market analysis and performance tracking

Robust research resources including market insights and educational content

Customer Service

24/7 customer support available via phone and online chat

24/7 customer support with dedicated financial advisors for premium accounts

Mobile App Experience

Highly rated mobile app with seamless navigation and trading capability

User-friendly mobile app with features for tracking and managing investments

Retirement Planning Tools

Offers you calculators and planning tools for retirement goal setting and progress tracking

Provides you retirement planning tools along with automated investment strategies

Education Resources

Comprehensive educational resources including webinars and tutorials for all investment levels

Strong educational content with courses, articles, and tools for investors

Target Audience

Appeals to both novice and experienced investors seeking flexibility and low-cost options

Targets investors seeking hands-off management and robust diversification

Customization

Limited customization; mostly adheres to Fidelity’s pre-selected options

Highly customizable portfolios tailored to individual preferences and risk tolerance

Withdrawal Flexibility

Flexible withdrawal options based on IRA type

Withdrawal policies aligned with general IRA regulations

Mobile Access

Excellent mobile access with comprehensive features

Good mobile access, focused on account overview and management

Additional Features

Offers you health savings accounts and estate planning tools

Integration with Schwab’s broader financial services offerings

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Standout Features

Fidelity Investments IRA

Instead of Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA consider Fidelity Investments IRA  due to its:

  • Innovative retirement tools enhancing planning capabilities
  • Flexible investment choices which cater to diverse strategies
  • Accessible educational resources supporting investor learning
  • Comprehensive robo-advisory services
  • Competitive fee structure which minimizes account expenses
  • Customizable portfolios for tailored investments
  • User-friendly platform promoting seamless navigation
  • Robust security measures protecting customer data

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

Consider Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA over Fidelity Investments IRA  due to its

  • Dynamic portfolio construction aligning with individual goals
  • Comprehensive asset allocation across multiple asset classes
  • Flexible investment options for various risk profiles
  • Integrated cash management with competitive interest rates
  • User-friendly interface simplifying investment tracking
  • Cost-effective investment with zero advisory fees
  • Automated rebalancing maintaining target allocation effortlessly

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Rebalancing Frequency

Choosing the right IRA provider can significantly impact your retirement savings, especially when it comes to rebalancing frequency. Fidelity Investments and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios both offer robust options for IRA accounts, but both have distinct approaches to rebalancing that you should consider.

Fidelity Investments IRA offers a proactive rebalancing strategy. You enjoy the benefit of automatic rebalancing at a minimum of every six months. This frequency allows you to maintain your desired asset allocation, ensuring your investments remain aligned with your goals and risk tolerance.

On the other hand, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA follows a more dynamic rebalancing strategy. This service rebalances your portfolio automatically whenever your asset allocation deviates by a specific threshold. You experience adjustments whenever a particular investment exceeds or falls below a designated percentage of your total portfolio.

In summary, you find that Fidelity Investments IRA focuses on periodic rebalancing, ensuring a disciplined approach to maintaining your asset allocation. Meanwhile, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA emphasizes a flexible, threshold-based strategy that adapts to market fluctuations.

Both strategies have merits, depending on your investment philosophy. If you prefer a consistent, scheduled approach, Fidelity suits you well. However, if you lean toward a more dynamic strategy that responds to market movements, Schwab provides an attractive option.

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Tax Management

Fidelity Investments IRA and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA offer distinct approaches to tax management, impacting your investment strategy and potential returns.

With Fidelity Investments IRA, you enjoy a flexible strategy that allows you to actively manage your tax implications. Fidelity offers tax-loss harvesting, a strategy that helps you offset gains by selling underperforming assets. This proactive approach enables you to minimize your tax burden while maximizing your investment potential.

On the other hand, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA takes a more automated route. You benefit from a diversified portfolio designed to manage risk and enhance returns, but it does not offer traditional tax-loss harvesting. Instead, Schwab focuses on tax-efficient investments and rebalancing strategies, which means you receive regular portfolio adjustments without incurring unnecessary taxes.

Both platforms provide tax-efficient investment options, but you experience more hands-on control with Fidelity. You decide when to realize gains or losses based on your tax situation. Schwab, meanwhile, simplifies the investment process and automates rebalancing, which can appeal to those seeking a more passive approach.

Ultimately, your choice hinges on your investment style and tax management preferences. If you value active involvement and personalized strategies, Fidelity Investments IRA suits you well. If you prefer a hands-off experience with automated adjustments, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA aligns with your needs.

Pros and Cons of Fidelity Investments IRA

Consider Fidelity Investments IRA instead of Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA because it:

  • Provide diverse investment options across categories
  • Offer commission-free trades for U.S. stocks
  • Allow easy access to comprehensive research tools
  • Feature no account minimums for opening
  • Support Roth, Traditional, and Rollover IRAs
  • Offer strong customer support through multiple channels
  • Give access to a user-friendly mobile app
  • Provide robust retirement planning tools and resources

Consider Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA  and ignore Fidelity Investments IRA  as you may

  • Require additional fees for some mutual funds
  • Limit in-person branches compared to competitors
  • Impose short-term trading fees on some investments
  • Restrict access to some international markets
  • Charge fees for certain advisory services
  • Limit integration with certain third-party apps
  • Require active management for personalized strategies
  • Provide fewer promotions for new account holders

Pros and Cons of Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA

Ignore Fidelity Investments IRA and opt for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA because it

  • Include diverse asset allocation
  • Simplify investment management for retirement
  • Provide tax-loss harvesting for added value
  • Offer a user-friendly digital experience
  • Deliver low-cost management fees on balance
  • Utilize automatic rebalancing to reduce risk
  • Feature SIPC insurance for extra protection
  • Allow goal tracking with financial planning tools
  • Encourage diversified long-term investment growth

Consider  Fidelity Investments IRA instead of Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA, as you may:

  • Require a $5,000 minimum to open
  • Limit customization for advanced investors’ needs
  • Delay responses from human advisors sometimes
  • Mandate a high cash allocation in portfolios
  • Restrict certain retirement account transfer processes
  • Exclude 24/7 live support availability
  • Impose limits on international investment choices
  • Provide no access to self-directed accounts

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Customer Reviews

When it comes to customer reviews, both  have garnered feedback from reputable users.

Fidelity’s IRA holds an impressive 4.7-star rating, with users highlighting its $0 account minimum, commission-free trading, and robust retirement planning resources. Fidelity Go, its robo-advisor, is praised for being ideal for beginners with small balances. Negative reviews occasionally mention the platform’s complexity for users unfamiliar with investing.

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA similarly enjoys a 4.5-star rating. Users appreciate its automated investing features and the lack of advisory fees. The portfolio’s diversification across ETFs and low-cost approach make it a top choice for hands-off investors. However, some users express frustration with the high cash allocation in portfolios, which can reduce growth potential during strong market periods.

Fidelity Investments IRA vs Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA: Competitors

If you’re considering alternatives to Fidelity Investments IRA and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA, there are several strong competitors worth exploring. Each option brings unique strengths that can better suit your needs depending on your investment goals.

Betterment stands out with its low-cost, comprehensive investment platform. You benefit from automatic rebalancing, tax-loss harvesting for all account sizes, and access to human financial planners without a high minimum investment requirement.

If you’re seeking a simple, automated investment experience with a low minimum, consider Wealthfront. Wealthfront excels with its daily tax-loss harvesting, which can help you save on taxes more efficiently than Schwab, which offers tax-loss harvesting only for larger accounts.

SoFi Invest is ideal if you want no management fees and access to unlimited financial planning. SoFi offers a more hands-on approach without account minimums, making it a more accessible option than Schwab’s $5,000 minimum. You also get perks like cryptocurrency trading and career coaching, which are not available with Fidelity or Schwab.

Lastly, consider Vanguard Digital Advisor offers a blend of low-cost index fund investing with automated management. Vanguard’s focus on minimizing fees and maximizing long-term returns through its renowned index funds makes it a strong alternative if you prefer low-cost, passive investing.

Pro Tips

To make the right choice between Fidelity Investments IRA and Schwab Intelligent IRA use these pro tips:

  • Compare fees to avoid hidden charges and unnecessary expenses
  • Consider tax advantages for long-term retirement savings growth
  • Explore investment options that align with your financial goals 
  • Analyze the robo-advisor features for hands-off portfolio management
  • Look into rebalancing strategies for maintaining portfolio balance
  • Research withdrawal rules to prevent unexpected penalties
  • Verify account protection for safeguarding your investment

Recap

Fidelity Investments IRA offers a wide array of investment options, including mutual funds, stocks, and bonds, giving you flexibility in your portfolio. It also features low fees and no account minimums, making it accessible for everyone.

On the other hand, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios IRA focuses on automated investment management, allowing you to enjoy a hands-off approach. You benefit from a diversified portfolio that adjusts based on market conditions.

Related Articles

Become a

S'witty Kiwi Credit Insider!

Get the latest credit tips and hacks in your inbox!