Debt Settlement Pros and Cons

(May 2024)

Debt Settlement Pros and Cons

In This Article


Struggling with a mountain of debt? Consider debt settlement as a way out. Pay back just a fraction of what you owe and regain control of your finances.

But note that it’s vital to grasp the pros and cons. It offers debt relief, avoids bankruptcy and saves you money. However, it negatively impacts your credit score and is time-consuming.

Explore the ins and outs, benefits, drawbacks, and tips to help you make informed decisions.

To recognize debt settlement pros and cons:

  1. Know What Debt Settlement Is
  2. Get to Know Debt Settlement Options
  3. Understand the Process of Debt Settlement
  4. Comprehend the Pros of Debt Settlement
  5. Assess the Cons of Debt Settlement
  6. Learn Tips for Debt Settlement Approval


Want to learn more? Keep reading.

1. Know What Debt Settlement Is

To examine debt settlement pros and cons, know what debt settlement is.

Debt settlement sorts out your unpaid debt – you pay back way less than what you owe – usually somewhere between 10% to 50% of your original debt.

You can either give debt settlement a shot on your own or get some backup from a debt settlement company. Just keep an eye out for trustworthy companies – some ask for cash up front, make false promises, or just drop the ball completely.

Debt settlement rules differ from state to state. Do your homework on the rules and laws for debt settlement in your state.

2. Get to Know Debt Settlement Options

It is important to get to know your debt settlement options.

Do-It-Yourself Debt Settlement

Contact your creditors to negotiate debt reduction. You can do it alone or with help. It can save you money and give you control, but it’s risky and time-consuming.

To negotiate with creditors on your own:

  • Contact your credit card issuer, and request the relevant department.
  • Clearly explain your financial situation without oversharing.
  • Propose a reasonable payment based on your ability.
  • Aim to settle for 50% or less, a common goal.
  • Be ready to negotiate and provide income proof.
  • Carefully understand settlement terms.
  • Request written confirmation before payment.
  • Review your credit report and fix errors post-settlement.

Professional Debt Settlement

Hire a company to negotiate with creditors. It saves on interest and bankruptcy but can harm your credit and may have fees.

Debt Settlement Program

Join a program where you stop paying creditors and deposit money into an account the company manages. It negotiates and pays off your debt, but hurts your credit and leads to fees or legal actions.

3. Understand the Process of Debt Settlement

To comprehend the pros and cons of debt settlement, understand the process of debt settlement.

Follow the steps below:

Contact a Pro

First, reach out to a debt settlement company or lawyer for help. You can find reputable ones online or through the National Association of Consumer Advocates.

Stop Payments

Pause paying your creditors and save that money in a separate account. This shows you’re in financial trouble and serious about settling. Be aware, this harms your credit score and triggers collection actions.


Be patient. Negotiating with creditors takes time, maybe months or years. The final deal outlines how much you pay, typically in a lump sum or instalments, and forego the rest of your debt.

Payment & Confirmation

Pay the final amount to your creditors and get written confirmation that your debt is settled. Don’t forget to pay the fees to your settlement company or lawyer, and keep in mind that you owe taxes on the forgiven debt.

Rebuild Your Finances

After settling, focus on rebuilding your credit. Check your credit report for errors, pay bills on time, maintain low credit card balances, and apply for new credit cautiously. Consider seeking advice from a credit counsellor or financial planner to stay on track.

4. Comprehend the Pros of Debt Settlement

It is necessary to comprehend the pros of debt settlement before you go ahead.

Below, are the benefits of debt settlement:

Lowers Your Debt

Negotiate with creditors to slash your debt, paying less than what you owe. Watch your total debt shrink significantly.

Offers Debt Relief

Regain control of your finances and work toward a debt-free life. Debt settlement is your path to relief.

Settles with One Payment

Seal the deal with a single lump-sum payment or a series of payments. Visualize the end point of your debt repayment journey.

Avoids Bankruptcy

Skip the heavy consequences of bankruptcy. Debt settlement offers an alternative to steer clear of its long-term drawbacks.

Boosts Flexibility

Manage your finances with more freedom. Trim your debt so you have more resources for other financial needs or investments.

Saves You Money

You score big savings when you settle for less than your original debt. Enjoy more funds for emergencies or future financial plans.

Speeds Up Repayment

Fast-track your debt clearance. Say goodbye to making minimum payments over ages – debt settlement gets you moving.

Offers Expert Help

Team up with skilled debt settlement pros who know the ropes. Expert guidance is your secret weapon in the process.

Aids Credit Recovery

Though your credit scores wobble initially, successful debt settlement offers a clean slate. Rebuild your credit gradually and start anew.

5. Assess the Cons of Debt Settlement

It is essential to assess the cons of debt settlement.

Challenges that occur with debt settlement are:

Hurts Your Credit Score

Debt settlement harms your credit score. When you miss or lower payments, credit bureaus take note, dragging down your score. This makes future loans or credit harder to get.

Leads to Tax Issues

Remember, forgiven debt counts as taxable income. Prepare for potential IRS taxes on the debt you settle, adding to your financial load.

Depends on Willing Creditors

Not all creditors play along. Some go legal or aggressive with collections, causing more financial stress and possible legal tangles.

Comes with Fees

Be cautious of fees from debt settlement services. Fees range from a cut of your debt to a flat charge. Be sure the costs are fair and reasonable.

Can Add to Debt

Interest, late fees, and penalties can pile up while you settle. This inflates your total debt, erasing the savings you hope for.

Takes Time

Brace for a lengthy process. It takes months or years to settle all your debts. Patience is key during this uncertain time.

Limits Future Credit

After debt settlement, getting new credit or loans gets tough. Lenders shy away from individuals who settle debts, making future financing a challenge.

6. Learn Tips for Debt Settlement Approval

Settling a debt varies based on factors like the debt amount, your creditor’s cooperation, and how you plan to settle it. On average, it usually takes between three to six months, but in certain situations, it can stretch to two to four years.

You can improve your chances of getting approval quickly for debt settlement. Here’s a practical guide:

Do Your Homework

Research your debts, what you can afford to pay, and your alternatives. Check your credit report and score to understand your standing. Get your free credit report at and your score via NerdWallet or Credit Karma.

Be Realistic

Understand that debt settlement isn’t a magic fix. It’s a negotiation that takes time and compromise. Don’t expect creditors to accept super-low offers. Set achievable goals and be patient; this process takes months or years.

Take Initiative

Act swiftly, don’t wait until your accounts are in dire situations. Contact your creditors early, and explain your situation. Keep records of all your communications in writing.

Stay Flexible

Debt settlement isn’t one-size-fits-all. It varies depending on your circumstances and creditor policies. Be open to different offers and ready to make financial changes. Save for lump-sum payments or create a special account for settlements.

Exercise Caution

Be aware of the risks. Debt settlement can harm your credit score, tax situation, and future borrowing ability. Watch out for scams in the industry. Research and choose a reputable settlement company. Read and understand all terms before signing any agreement.


To understand debt settlement pros and cons, first understand what debt settlement is. Then, know the various options available. Next, comprehend the debt settlement process, explore its pros and cons, and learn practical tips for gaining debt settlement approval.

Related Articles

Become a

S'witty Kiwi Credit Insider!

Get the latest credit tips and hacks in your inbox!