Best Car Insurance for Teens

of February 2025

Best-Car-Insurance-for-Teens

In This Article

Due to their statistically higher accident rate, insurance companies view teenage drivers as high-risk drivers. This implies that teen drivers’ car insurance can be highly costly.

Read this to get the following list of top teen-focused auto insurance providers based on variables including cost, savings, and client support.

Let’s ride on!

1. Allstate
2. Progressive
3. State Farm
4. Geico.
5. Nationwide
Overview of the Best Car Insurance for Teens
How to Choose the Best Car Insurance for Teens
Pros and Cons of the Best Car Insurance for Teens
What to watch out for
Pro Tips
Recap

1. Allstate

Allstate is one of the best in the insurance game, with a solid reputation for providing top-notch car, home, and life insurance policies. With a massive network of agents and an easy-to-use online platform, Allstate is a popular choice for teens looking for peace of mind when it comes to protecting their assets.

Pros

  • Known for its reliability and customer service.
  • Offers a wide range of insurance policies, from auto and home to life and umbrella coverage.
  • Has a user-friendly online platform and a huge network of agents to help you find the best coverage for your needs.
  • Offers various discounts to help you save money on your premiums.
  • Provides 24/7 claim assistance. Allstate’s claim assistance is available around the clock, which is super handy if you need help with a claim in the middle of the night or on the weekend.

Cons

  • High premiums: Allstate can have higher premiums compared to other insurers, especially for younger drivers or those with a less-than-stellar driving record.
  • Slow claims processing: Some customers have reported that Allstate’s claims processing can be a bit sluggish, which can be frustrating if you’re waiting for a settlement.
  • Limited customer service options: While Allstate does have online support, some customers find that their customer service options are a bit limited compared to other insurers.
  • Solid reputation for customer service and transparency.
  • Wide network of agents and digital options, you can choose how you want to interact with them.
  • Slogan: “You’re in good hands with Allstate.”

2. Progressive

Progressive Insurance is a big name in the game, offering a variety of insurance options like auto, home, and renters. They’re known for their “Name Your Price” tool, which lets you customize coverage options to fit your budget. Progressive also offers a mobile app, and they’re known for their creative and memorable advertising campaigns.

Pros

  • “Name Your Price” tool: This handy tool lets you set your budget, and Progressive shows you coverage options that fit the bill.
  • User-friendly website: The website is easy to navigate, making it a breeze to manage your policy, pay bills, and get quotes.
  • Mobile app: The app lets you access your policy, file claims, and pay bills from your smartphone.
  • Discounts: Progressive offers discounts for safe drivers, multi-policy holders, and more.
  • Solid reputation: With high ratings for customer satisfaction and financial strength, you can trust Progressive to provide reliable coverage and a good customer experience.

Cons

  • Claims processing: Some customers have complained about lengthy claims processing times and difficulty getting approved.
  • Premium increases: After filing a claim, some customers have seen their premiums increase, which can be a bummer.
  • Customer service: Some customers report less-than-stellar customer service experiences, which can be a red flag.
  • Limited comprehensive coverage options: Progressive’s comprehensive coverage options might not be as robust as some other insurers.
  • Variety of coverage options.
  • User-friendly digital tools for managing insurance.
  • Discounts for drivers with good driving records.

3. State Farm

State Farm, a household name in the US insurance industry, boasts a rich history and a strong presence. Their slogan is “Like a good neighbour, State Farm is there,” and they’ve got a wide range of coverage options to choose from, like liability, comprehensive, collision, and more. And their optional coverage options are pretty sweet too, like roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and accident forgiveness.

Pros

  • Coverage options: State Farm has got you covered with a bunch of different insurance options, from auto and home to life and health.
  • Reputation: You can trust State Farm to be legitimate because they have been in the insurance business for a very long time.
  • Discounts: State Farm offers discounts for bundling policies, safe driving, and more.
  • Customer service: State Farm’s has a solid reputation for taking care of their customers with great customer service.

Cons

  • Claims handling can be a bit of a mixed bag: While some customers have had positive experiences, others have reported issues with approval or payment delays.
  • Premium hikes are a possibility: While State Farm is generally known for reasonable rates, some customers have reported rate increases after making claims, which can be frustrating.
  • Coverage limitations: Some customers have reported that State Farm’s coverage options might not provide enough protection if you’re in a serious accident or if you have an expensive car.
  • Limited options for exotic or rare cars: If you’re cruising in a vintage Porsche or a rare Lamborghini, State Farm’s coverage might not offer the specialized protection you need.
  • Personalized service and guidance from a dedicated agent.
  • Reliable and established insurance provider with a strong reputation.
  • Multiple policies for potential discounts and a streamlined insurance experience.

4. Geico

Geico, standing for Government Employees Insurance Company, is a major American auto insurance provider, though it offers coverage for a variety of vehicles and other needs.

Geico is one of the cheapest car insurance companies for adding a teen driver to a policy, which makes it worth a look if you want cheap auto insurance.

Pros

  • Coverage options: Geico’s got you covered with a range of insurance products, from auto and home to renters and life.
  • Discounts: Geico’s got discounts for all sorts of things, like bundling policies, safe driving, and more.
  • Easy claims process: Geico’s got an easy claims process.
  • Low rates: Geico’s rates are often lower than other insurers, which means more cash in your pocket.

Cons

  • Limited coverage options: Geico doesn’t offer as many coverage options as some other insurers, so you might not be able to get the coverage you need.
  • Claims handling: While Geico’s claims process is generally considered easy, some customers have reported issues with communication and responsiveness during the claims process.
  • Customer service: While Geico’s customer service is generally well-regarded, some customers have reported issues with communication and responsiveness.
  • Absence of gap coverage: Geico doesn’t typically offer gap insurance, which can be important if your car is totaled and the value paid by your insurance isn’t enough to cover the loan or lease payoff.
  • Higher rates for some drivers: Geico is known for affordability, but rates can be higher for certain profiles, such as new drivers, drivers with accidents or violations on their record, or those with poor credit scores.
  • Geico is a private American auto insurance company with headquarters in Chevy Chase, Maryland.
  • In addition to auto insurance, Geico provides motorcycle, ATV, boat, snowmobile, travel, pet, and more insurance options.

5. Nationwide

Nationwide is a well-established mutual insurance company with a major focus on various coverage options for different vehicles and driving needs. They’ve got customizable coverage options like liability, comprehensive, collision, medical payments, and more, which let you pick and choose what you need. Plus, their online services make it easy to manage your policy, get quotes, and file claims, all from the comfort of your couch.

Pros

  • Coverage for all sorts of stuff: From auto and home to life, health, pet, and business insurance, Nationwide has got you covered.
  • Customizable coverage: Want to add extra coverage for your precious heirlooms or your furry friend? Nationwide offers optional coverage options to make sure you’ve got the protection you need.
  • Commitment to customer service: Nationwide places a strong emphasis on giving customers a satisfying experience. They can help clients with their insurance needs through their network of agents.
  • Strong financial stability: With a solid reputation and financial stability, you can trust that Nationwide will be there for you when you need them and that they’ll treat you fairly and respectfully.

Cons

  • Premium hikes: Like many insurance companies, Nationwide sometimes raises premiums after you make a claim. This can be frustrating if you’re already dealing with a tough situation.
  • Coverage limitations: Nationwide’s coverage options might not be the most comprehensive out there, so it’s important to read the fine print and compare coverage levels before committing.
  • Limited availability: Nationwide isn’t available in all states.
  • Slow or unhelpful customer service: Some customers have reported that Nationwide’s customer service can be slow to respond or unhelpful when dealing with claims or policy questions.
  • Nationwide is a mutual insurance company, and affiliated companies, commonly shortened to Nationwide, are a group of large U.S. insurance and financial services companies based in Columbus, Ohio.

Overview of the Best Car Insurance for Teens

Overview-of-the-Best-Car-Insurance-for-Teens

If you’re a teen driver, shopping for car insurance can be a bit of a wild ride. But don’t worry, you’ve got options! Here’s a quick rundown of some popular choices: Allstate, Progressive, State Farm, Geico, and Nationwide.

How to Choose the Best Car Insurance for Teens

Choosing the best car insurance for teens is like finding the perfect prom date: it takes some research, smarts, and a little bit of trust.

Here’s how to navigate the insurance world and score a policy that’s safe and affordable:

Research

Look into different insurance companies and compare their rates and coverage options.

Talk to your agent

A good insurance agent can help you figure out the best coverage for your teen and recommend discounts to help keep premiums low.

Compare coverage options

Make sure the policy includes liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.

Discounts

Insurance companies often offer discounts for good grades, driver’s education courses, or monitoring programs. Ask about these to lower premiums.

Claim-filing process

Read reviews of the insurance company’s claim-filing process. You want a company that’s fast, reliable, and easy to work with in case of an accident.

Payment options

Look into payment options like monthly installments or discounts for paying in full.

Pros and Cons of the Best Car Insurance for Teens

  • Multiple coverage options.
  • Variety of discounts.
  • Strong reputation.
  • Higher premiums for younger drivers.
  • Complaints about claim processing.

What to watch out for

When looking for car insurance for teens, here are some red flags to watch out for:

High premiums

Some insurers charge higher rates for teen drivers because they’re considered high-risk. Make sure to compare rates to find the best deal.

Limited coverage

Some insurers may offer cheaper plans, but they may not provide enough coverage. Make sure the policy has liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.

Slow claims processing

Some insurers may take a long time to process claims, leaving you stranded. Look for insurers with a quick and efficient claims process.

Pro Tips

Pro-Tips-for-the-Best-Car-Insurance-for-Teens

Here are some pro tips to help you navigate the process of shopping for car insurance for teens:

  • Compare rates: Get quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate for your teen driver.
  • Choose higher coverage limits: Opt for higher coverage limits to ensure you’re protected in case of an accident.
  • Consider usage-based insurance: Usage-based insurance programmes can save you money if your teen drives safely.
  • Talk to your teen about safe driving: Emphasize the importance of safe driving to your teen to help avoid accidents.

Recap

Shopping for car insurance as a teen can feel like a rollercoaster ride, but don’t worry! You’ve got options, and some of the best ones are Geico, Allstate, Progressive, State Farm, Geico, and Nationwide. These insurers offer affordable rates, good discounts, comprehensive coverage options, and user-friendly apps.

But remember, every teen driver is unique, so it’s important to shop around and compare quotes from multiple companies to find the best fit for your needs. And, if you’re a safe driver with a good record, you might even qualify for special discounts, which can help you save money on car insurance as a teen driver.

Become a

S'witty Kiwi Credit Insider!

Get the latest credit tips and hacks in your inbox!