Ally Invest vs TradeStation

(November 2024)

In This Article

Our Verdict

You’ll find that Ally Invest and TradeStation each offer strong options for different kinds of investors and traders. You should consider Ally Invest if you’re looking for an accessible, low-cost platform that’s perfect for newer investors or those who want a convenient all-in-one solution for banking and investing. Its integration with Ally Bank products, competitive pricing, and user-friendly interface make it a great choice for beginners or anyone wanting to streamline their finances.

On the other hand, TradeStation is ideal if you’re an active or technical trader. Its advanced tools, comprehensive charting capabilities, and robust strategy development and automation features make it stand out. While it may have a steeper learning curve, TradeStation is the go-to for serious day traders, options strategists, and those interested in creating and testing custom trading systems.

After a thorough comparison, Ally invest is a clear winner.

Why Choose Ally Invest

Choose Ally Invest if you want a user-friendly, low-cost brokerage with solid all-around capabilities and integration with banking products.

Who Ally Invest Is Best For

Ally Invest is particularly well-suited for you for the following reasons:

  • Start with Ally Invest if you’re a new or intermediate investor
  • Opt for Ally Invest if you’re a buy-and-hold investor
  • Choose Ally Invest if you want to consolidate finances
  • Consider Ally Invest if you’re an options trader
  • Use Ally Invest if you’re a mobile-first investor

Who Ally Invest Is Not Right For

  • If you relate with any or all written below, then consider other options:

    • Avoid Ally Invest if you’re an advanced day trade
    • Skip Ally Invest if you’re a forex trader: It does not offer forex trading
    • Reconsider Ally Invest if you’re developing automated trading systems
    • Look elsewhere if you want direct market access

Why Choose TradeStation

Choose TradeStation if you’re a serious trader looking for professional-grade tools, advanced charting, and the ability to develop and automate trading strategies.

Who TradeStation Is Best For

 TradeStation is ideal for you if you:

  • Involve in active day trading
  • Operate as a technical analyst
  • Prefer to be an options strategist
  • Work as an algo trader or system developer

Who TradeStation Is Not Right For

Avoid TradeStation because you may:

    • Struggle due to the steep learning curve and advanced features
    • Dislike buy-and-hold investments
    • Value forex trading
    • Seek comprehensive financial planning tools

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: Main Differences

TradeStation stands out as the winner. It excels with its advanced charting and technical analysis tools, which are crucial for experienced traders.

 

Ally Invest

TradeStation

Ideal For

Ally Invest is ideal for newer to intermediate investors, buy-and-hold strategists, and those looking to integrate their investing with Ally banking products. Its user-friendly interface and educational resources make it accessible for those just starting their investing journey.

TradeStation caters to more experienced, active traders who require advanced analytical tools, customizable charting, and the ability to develop automated trading systems. It’s best suited for day traders, technical analysts, and those trading complex options or futures strategies.

Pricing

Ally Invest offers commission-free stock and ETF trades, with options trades at $0.50 per contract. There are no account minimums for self-directed accounts. Managed portfolios have a $100 minimum and charge a 0.30% annual advisory fee, or no fee for accounts with 30% allocated to cash.

TradeStation also provides commission-free stock and ETF trades, with options at $0.60 per contract. Futures trades are $1.50 per contract ($0.50 for micro e-minis). TradeStation has eliminated its previous account minimums, making it more accessible to a broader range of traders.

Integrations

Ally Invest integrates seamlessly with Ally Bank products, allowing you to manage your investments, savings, loans, and other financial products from a single dashboard. This integration enables easy cash management and transfers between accounts.

TradeStation offers integration with TradingView, a popular charting and social networking platform for traders. It also provides APIs for developers to create custom integrations and trading applications.

Standout Features

Ally Invest stands out for its high-yield savings options, allowing investors to earn competitive interest rates on cash balances. Its “Smart Score” feature, powered by TipRanks, provides an easy-to-understand rating system for stocks based on various factors.

TradeStation’s standout features include its robust charting capabilities, strategy development tools, and the ability to fully automate trading systems. Its simulated trading environment is particularly valuable for testing strategies without risking real capital.

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: Standout Features

TradeStation is the clear winner here. It offers industry-leading charting capabilities, powerful strategy development, and automation tools.

Explore Ally Invest’s features:

  • Benefit From An Integrated Banking And Investing Platform: Ally Invest’s seamless integration with Ally Bank products provides a comprehensive financial management solution. Users can effortlessly move funds between high-yield savings accounts and investment accounts, streamlining cash management.
  • Leverage Smart Score Stock Ratings: Powered by TipRanks, this feature delivers an easy-to-understand 1-10 rating for stocks based on various factors. This helps you quickly assess potential investments without deep fundamental analysis.
  • Enjoy High-Yield Cash Management: Ally Invest offers competitive interest rates on cash balances (currently up to 4.20% APY), with options to automatically sweep unused funds into high-yield savings accounts.
  • Utilize the Intuitive Mobile App: The well-designed mobile app enables comprehensive account management and trading on the go, making it simple for you to stay connected to your portfolio.
  • Take Advantage of Competitive Options Trading Tools: Although geared towards less advanced traders, Ally Invest provides solid options analysis tools and competitive per-contract pricing.

Explore TradeStation’s features:

  • Harness Advanced Charting and Technical Analysis: TradeStation offers some of the best charting capabilities in the industry, with a vast array of built-in studies and the ability to create custom indicators using its proprietary EasyLanguage.
  • Develop and Automate Strategies: You can create, test, and fully automate custom trading strategies using EasyLanguage or pre-built components. This feature is particularly valuable for algorithmic traders and system developers.
  • Benefit from a Robust Simulated Trading Environment: TradeStation’s paper trading platform delivers a full-featured environment for testing strategies and honing skills without risking real capital.
  • Utilize OptionStation Pro: This powerful tool facilitates complex options analysis and strategy development, catering to sophisticated options traders.
  • Use RadarScreen and Scanner: These real-time scanning tools help you quickly identify potential trading opportunities based on technical and fundamental criteria.

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: How to Use Ally Invest

  • Apply online for an Ally Invest Self-Directed Trading account, Robo Portfolio, or Personal Advice account.
  • Visit the Self-Directed Trading section and click on Start Trading to access the application. Provide your personal information
  • Select your preferred account type
  • Choose your funding options

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: How to Open an Account with TradeStation

  • Visit the website and sign up
  • Fill out the application form to begin the process.
  • Choose your account type and set up a username and password to initiate the Interactive Brokers application.
  • Upload the required documents:
  • Await account approval and then deposit funds into your account.
  • Obtain instructions for downloading the TradeStation Global platform and set up your workspaces.

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: Pros and Cons

Ally Invest takes the win for its balanced pros and cons.

Ally Invest

  • Offers commission-free stock and ETF trades with competitive options pricing.
  • Provides seamless integration with Ally Bank products for comprehensive financial management.
  • Features user-friendly platforms suitable for beginners and intermediate investors.
  • Earn high interest rates on cash balances (up to 4.20% APY).
  • Delivers solid educational resources and research tools for improving investing skills.
  • Includes “Smart Score” feature for quick stock assessment.
  • Requires no account minimums for self-directed investing.
  • Supplies robust mobile app for on-the-go trading and account management.
  • Lacks advanced charting and technical analysis tools compared to platforms like TradeStation.
  • Excludes forex trading options
  • Omits direct market access for order routing.
  • Restricts some trading products (e.g., bonds, mutual funds) to broker-assisted trades.
  • Charges inactivity fees for accounts with low balances or trading activity.
  • Provides limited customization options for advanced traders.

Pros and Cons of TradeStation

  • Offers professional-grade trading platform with advanced charting and analysis tools.
  • Provides powerful strategy development and automation capabilities using EasyLanguage.
  • Features robust simulated trading environment for risk-free practice and strategy testing.
  • Includes real-time scanning tools (RadarScreen and Scanner) for identifying trading opportunities.
  • Presents advanced options analysis and trading tools through OptionStation Pro.
  • Obtain competitive pricing with commission-free stock and ETF trades.
  • Eliminates previous account minimums, increasing accessibility.
  • Allows API access for custom integrations and trading applications.
  • Presents a steep learning curve for new traders due to advanced features.
  • Lacks comprehensive fundamental research tools for long-term investors.
  • Excludes forex trading options.
  • Omits fractional share trading.
  • Provides limited educational resources compared to some competitors.
  • Charges fees for real-time market data beyond basic quotes.
  • Restricts some features to the desktop platform, limiting mobile functionality.
  • Requires separate accounts for different asset classes (e.g., equities, futures, crypto).

Ally Invest vs. TradeStation: Customer Reviews

Ally Invest emerges as the winner in customer reviews. It has received higher ratings for its user-friendly interface, seamless banking integration, and helpful educational resources.

Customer reviews for both Ally Invest and TradeStation are generally positive but highlight different strengths and target audiences. Ally Invest has received ratings of 4.4 from Nerd Wallet and 4.5 from Bankrate, while TradeStation scores 3.9 from Nerd Wallet and 3.7 from Forbes ADVISOR.

Ally Invest is commended for its user-friendly interface, seamless integration with Ally Bank products, and competitive pricing. New investors find it easy to use and appreciate the helpful educational resources. However, some users feel the platform’s tools might not meet the needs of very active or advanced traders. Positive feedback often mentions its ease of use for beginners, competitive interest rates, good customer service, and effective integration with Ally Bank accounts. Criticisms include limited advanced charting capabilities, occasional technical glitches, and a lack of some advanced order types.

TradeStation, on the other hand, is favored by experienced traders who value its advanced features and robust tools. The platform is praised for its powerful charting and technical analysis capabilities, as well as its strategy development and automation options. Users also appreciate the simulated trading environment for testing strategies. Positive reviews frequently highlight the platform’s advanced charting, ability to develop and automate custom strategies, fast order execution, and comprehensive options and futures trading capabilities. However, criticisms include a steep learning curve for new users, higher costs for some data feeds and advanced features, limited fundamental research tools, and occasional platform stability issues during high-volume trading.

Ally Invest and TradeStation: Competitors

While Ally Invest and TradeStation are strong contenders in the online brokerage space, several other platforms compete for your attention. Here’s how some key competitors stack up:

  • E*TRADE: E*TRADE offers a balance between user-friendly interfaces for beginners and more advanced tools for active traders. Like Ally Invest, it provides commission-free stock and ETF trades, but it also offers a wider range of no-transaction-fee mutual funds. E*TRADE’s options trading tools are particularly strong, rivaling those of TradeStation in some aspects. However, it lacks the deep strategy development and automation capabilities that TradeStation provides.
  • Interactive Brokers: Interactive Brokers (IBKR) is known for its advanced trading capabilities and access to global markets. It offers competitive pricing and may be a better choice than TradeStation for traders looking for international exposure. However, IBKR’s platform can be complex for beginners, and it doesn’t offer the same level of strategy automation as TradeStation.
  • Fidelity: Fidelity provides a well-rounded platform suitable for both beginners and more advanced investors. It offers commission-free trades, a wide range of research tools, and strong customer service. Fidelity’s Active Trader Pro platform competes with TradeStation for active traders, though it doesn’t offer the same level of customization and strategy development.
  • Robinhood: Robinhood targets newer, mobile-first investors with its streamlined app and commission-free trades. While it’s user-friendly like Ally Invest, it lacks the depth of features and educational resources. Robinhood doesn’t offer the advanced tools that TradeStation provides and has a more limited range of tradable assets.

Pro Tips

  • Assess Your Investing Style and Needs: Before choosing between Ally Invest and TradeStation, honestly evaluate your trading frequency, preferred asset classes, and the level of analysis tools you require. This will help you determine which platform aligns better with your needs.
  • Utilize Demo Accounts: Both Ally Invest and TradeStation offer simulated trading environments. Take advantage of these to test the platforms and their features before committing real money.
  • Consider Account Integration: If you already use Ally Bank products or plan to, the seamless integration with Ally Invest could streamline your financial management.
  • Evaluate Long-Term Costs: While both platforms offer commission-free stock and ETF trades, consider other potential costs such as data fees, inactivity charges, or costs for advanced features, especially if you plan to use TradeStation’s more sophisticated tools.
  • Leverage Educational Resources: Both platforms offer educational materials. Make use of these to improve your trading skills and maximize the platform’s capabilities.
  • Start Simple and Scale Up: If you’re new to investing, start with Ally Invest’s basic features and gradually explore more advanced tools as you gain experience. If choosing TradeStation, focus on mastering core functionalities before diving into complex strategy development.
  • Use Mobile Apps Strategically: While both platforms offer mobile apps, TradeStation’s advanced features are more limited on mobile. Plan your trading activities accordingly, using desktop access for more complex analysis and strategy development.
  • Explore Third-Party Integrations: TradeStation’s API capabilities allow for custom integrations. If you have specific needs not met by the native platform, investigate third-party tools or consider developing custom solutions.
  • Regularly Review and Adjust: As your trading style and needs evolve, periodically reassess whether your chosen platform still meets your requirements. Don’t hesitate to switch or use multiple platforms if necessary.

Recap

Ally Invest and TradeStation each excel in different areas suited to various investors and traders. Ally Invest is ideal for those seeking a user-friendly, cost-effective platform, particularly beginners or those who want to integrate their banking and investing. Its seamless integration with Ally Bank products and competitive pricing make it a solid choice for new and intermediate investors. However, it may not meet the needs of advanced traders due to its limited charting tools and lack of forex trading options.

Conversely, TradeStation caters to active and technical traders with its advanced charting, strategy development, and automation features. It is well-suited for experienced day traders, technical analysts, and those who develop custom trading strategies. Despite its steep learning curve and higher costs for some features, TradeStation’s powerful tools and simulated trading environment make it a strong choice for serious traders.

Related Articles

Become a

S'witty Kiwi Credit Insider!

Get the latest credit tips and hacks in your inbox!